When you work on climate, the news can often feel like one step forward, two steps back. But lately, ordinary people have been winning big victories to protect their communities — and our planet.
Last November, for example, President Biden announced at the UN climate talks in Scotland that the US will lead “by the power of our example” when it comes to transitioning off fossil fuels and cutting emissions.
Then, just two weeks later, his administration announced the largest sale of offshore drilling leases in US history. They’ve sold some 1.7 million acres in the Gulf of Mexico out of a staggering 81 million acres on offer.
The hypocrisy was galling, but there’s a lot more at stake than the bad symbolism. Burning this oil would be like putting 130 coal power plants online.
And offshore drilling is dangerous, as Gulf communities know well. The BP Deepwater Horizon disaster in 2010 was the largest oil spill in the history of offshore drilling. It killed 11 workers, damaged ecosystems, and devastated fishing communities, including the United Houma Nation.
But this time, Gulf communities are refusing to be a sacrifice zone — and they may be winning.
This January, they won a major victory against this egregious injustice. A federal district court found the analysis the government used to justify the lease sale seriously underestimated greenhouse gas emissions and other risks. Movements are now pressuring the Interior Department to let the ruling stand and end this disastrous lease sale.
People are winning victories over fossil fuel giants in other places, too.
On Feb. 3, a federal appeals court ordered the government to reconsider its analysis of the Mountain Valley Pipeline’s impact on endangered species. Just days before, the same court found that the government’s reviews allowing the pipeline to cut through the Jefferson National Forest were also flawed.
Together, these decisions could cause significant delays for the Virginia-West Virginia pipeline, and maybe even kill the project.
If that happens, communities near and far could breathe easier. The Mountain Valley Pipeline poses serious threats to water quality and ecosystems and increases landslide risks — with potentially catastrophic consequences for a pipeline carrying explosive gas. And if completed, the gas it would transport would produce as much carbon dioxide as 26 coal plants.
My colleague Gabrielle Colchete and I found in a 2020 report that the pipeline was putting vulnerable communities at particular risk. Its route snakes through West Virginia communities where poverty rates run 25% higher than average, while over half the Census tracts along the pipeline path there have below average life expectancy.
Not every win comes from the courts. To cap things off, the Los Angeles City Council voted to ban new oil drilling within city limits — and to start a process to phase out existing drilling.
Not to mention the carbon emitted by burning the oil extracted — and the methane emitted from the oil drilling operations — make a mockery of California’s lofty climate goals.
There’s still a hard fight ahead to end the toxic fossil fuel industry once and for all. Movements led by impacted frontline communities, working together through nationwide formations such as the Climate Justice Alliance, Indigenous Environmental Network, and the Build Back Fossil Free coalition, are working towards this goal.
But in the meantime, we need to celebrate these recent victories, to give us hope and inspiration for the struggles ahead.
Basav Sen directs the Climate Policy Program at the Institute for Policy Studies. This op-ed was distributed by OtherWords.org.
From The Progressive Populist, March 15, 2022
Blog | Current Issue | Back Issues | Essays | Links
About the Progressive Populist | How to Subscribe | How to Contact Us